Warm, softly focused bar-scene still from A Star Is Born (2018), with Jackson looking toward Ally.

A Star Is Born: A Different Kind of Prince Charming

I’ve watched it several times, and I still keep listening to the soundtrack.

Lady Gaga surprised me.

Her singing. Her acting. Both.

Here is my A Star Is Born review, short version:

A prince on a white horse, but with the story changed.

Fate and love. Envy and jealousy.

Rock bottom and giving up.

Opportunity for someone already prepared.

Addiction and obsession.

Of the five, the one that hit me hardest was opportunity for the prepared.

That is the outline. The details need a little explaining.

What is A Star Is Born about?

Short answer: A Star Is Born is a 2018 musical romantic drama directed by Bradley Cooper. Cooper plays Jackson Maine, an established musician struggling with alcohol and drug addiction. Lady Gaga plays Ally, whose singing catches his attention. He invites her onto his stage, and their relationship develops as her music reaches a wider audience. Sam Elliott plays Bobby Maine, and Dave Chappelle plays Noodles.

Warner Bros. lists the original theatrical release as October 5, 2018. At the 2019 Academy Awards, the film received eight nominations and won Best Original Song for “Shallow,” written by Lady Gaga, Mark Ronson, Anthony Rossomando, and Andrew Wyatt.

This is the fourth version of A Star Is Born: Janet Gaynor and Fredric March starred in the 1937 original, Judy Garland and James Mason in the 1954 version, and Barbra Streisand and Kris Kristofferson in the 1976 version.

Those are the movie facts. My starting point is simpler: I was surprised by Lady Gaga’s acting and singing.

The Lady Gaga surprise

Ally first catches Jackson’s attention while performing “La Vie en rose.” Later, he brings her onto a much larger stage to sing “Shallow” with him.

There is the singing in front of an audience. Then there are the conversations, arguments, and changes between the performances.

My surprise was not only about the voice. It was about the acting too.

A different kind of Prince Charming

I see a changed version of the prince on a white horse story here. The familiar outline is there: someone arrives, recognizes her, and opens a door. But many of the details are different.

Jackson hears Ally before a wider audience does. He encourages her to perform her own material. He is also already struggling with addiction when they meet. Her rise does not remove that struggle.

I wonder what happens to the rescue story when the person opening the door also needs help.

Spoiler warning: The sections below discuss major events, including the ending. Content note: addiction and suicide, without graphic detail.

Fate and love

A meeting after a performance brings Jackson and Ally together. Their first conversations lead to another invitation, then a shared stage, then a relationship.

Later, Ally supports Jackson through treatment. Near the end, she decides against continuing her tour so she can stay with him.

Fate and love are one of the pairs this film made me think about. There is the encounter that starts everything, and then there is everything that happens after it.

I find myself asking where fate ends and the choices inside love begin.

Envy and jealousy

Ally’s audience grows. Jackson criticizes the direction of her music and her changing image. The person who first encouraged her also argues with her as her success develops.

Those scenes give the theme of envy and jealousy something concrete to sit beside. The encouragement at the beginning and the conflict later are both part of the story.

I wonder how love and jealousy can occupy the same relationship.

Rock bottom and giving up

At the Grammy Awards, an intoxicated Jackson disrupts Ally’s acceptance speech. He later enters rehabilitation and apologizes to her.

Treatment is part of the story before the ending, not something the film skips. After he returns home, Ally’s representative, Rez, confronts him and claims he will damage her future. Later, Jackson dies by suicide.

That is the plot, not proof that his death was inevitable or that Ally caused it. The film explicitly rejects her self blame afterward.

I wonder how to think about rock bottom and giving up without treating them as the same thing.

Addiction and obsession

Jackson’s alcohol and drug use are present from the beginning. They continue as his relationship with Ally develops, affect his behavior in public and private, and lead to treatment.

The relationship also becomes entangled with decisions about music, performance, and staying together. Ally’s planned tour becomes one of those decisions.

Addiction and obsession are another pair the film made me think about. They are themes to consider here, not interchangeable diagnoses.

I wonder where attachment becomes obsession, and what love can and cannot carry.

Opportunity for the one who is prepared

Before Jackson offers Ally a stage, she can already sing. She has already written material. He hears part of what becomes “Shallow” before their concert performance together.

When he first encounters her at the drag bar, she is performing “La Vie en rose” for an audience. She is singing before he approaches her, not auditioning at his request. The film shows her performing before he invites her to perform with him.

Before that first night is over, she also sings him part of a song she has written. The story shows both her singing and her songwriting before the shared concert appearance. Later, she steps out in front of his audience to sing “Shallow” with him.

The invitation changes who can hear her. It does not create her ability from nothing.

This is where I think about opportunity for the person who is prepared.

I wonder whether the opportunity is the discovery itself, or the moment preparation finally has somewhere to go.

No matter where you work, if you stay focused on your own work and give it your best, some kind of opportunity tends to come along, big or small. And if you’re ready when it comes, I think you can really catch it.

In the movie, Ally had already written a lot of songs long before anyone noticed her. Even on a small bar stage, she performed like there were tens of thousands of people in front of her, and she gave it everything. She was already someone ready for the big stage.

I wasn’t. Far more often than not, I wasn’t ready. Watching her, I remembered the times I let opportunities slip away.

My score

★★★★★ 4.1

What this review comes back to

I started with surprise at Lady Gaga’s acting and singing.

Then the altered Prince Charming story gave me more to think about: fate and love, envy and jealousy, rock bottom and giving up, opportunity for someone prepared, addiction and obsession.

That is the shape of my review. One changed story, and several things to think about inside it.

Sources

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top